Machine Man #3

Machine Man #3

In Marvel, Reviews by T. Andrew WahlLeave a Comment

“Not to cut the point too fine, it was not an enjoyable thing to work on.”Penciler Herb Trimpe, on collaborating with Barry Windsor-Smith on Machine Man
(From Back Issue #25, December 2007)

Review

Title: “Rim of the Ancient Wrecker!”
Synopsis: Baintronics’ forces track an escaped Midnight Wrecker to Sanctuary – leading to a showdown between Machine Man and Iron Man 2020.

Writer: Tom DeFalco
Penciler: Herb Trimpe
Inker: Barry Windsor-Smith

This Machine Man miniseries (see reviews of #1 and #2) is a strange, transitional series. In terms of concept and character treatment, it has much in common with the more realistic, grittier fare of the emerging Copper Age. And, of course, Barry Windsor-Smith’s stylized art holds its own with comics of any era. That makes Tom DeFalco’s script the weak link here. Be clear: This story is quite good. But there are little quirks – awkward exposition to provide back story, occasionally clunky dialogue, etc. – that dates this one to the Bronze Age.

Grade: A-

Cool factor: Machine Man vs. Iron Man 2020! By Barry Windsor-Smith!

Second opinion: Recommended by The Slings & Arrows Comic Guide (second edition).

Character Quotable
“I’ve been on the defensive ever since I was resurrected … now it’s my turn!Machine Man, one pissed-offed android
Machine Man #3

MACHINE MAN #3
Published and © by Marvel, December 1984
Cover by Barry Windsor-Smith

Your Take

What did you think of this issue?

Collected Editions

Machine Man #3 is reprinted in:

Leave a Comment